How PSA Grades Pokémon Cards: A Critical Guide to the PSA Grading Standards

November 12, 2026 10:10 am

If you have ever looked at a freshly pulled card and thought “that’s a 10”, you are in good company, and very often you will be disappointed. A PSA grade is not decided by the person who owns the card. It is the grader’s call, made against PSA’s published grading standards and their own experience. This guide walks through what those standards actually say, how to check a card yourself before you submit or buy, and why a careful, critical eye matters more than optimism.

Start with the source: PSA’s own grading standards

The most reliable reference for how PSA grades is PSA itself. Their grading standards page sets out the 1–10 scale, the centring tolerances and the reasons a card may not receive a numerical grade at all. We would strongly recommend reading it in full before you submit anything, and coming back to it whenever you are unsure. Summaries like this one (ours included) are a starting point, not a substitute.

What PSA says a PSA 10 is

PSA describes a PSA 10 as “a virtually perfect card”. Its standards call for four perfectly sharp corners, sharp focus and full original gloss. A PSA 10 must also be free of staining of any kind, although PSA notes an allowance may be made for a slight printing imperfection if it does not impair the overall appeal of the card.

The key word is virtually. A card that looks flawless at arm’s length can still show a soft corner, a faint edge nick or a print line under magnification and good light, and that is where most hoped-for 10s come back as something else.

Centring: the numbers behind the eye test

Centring is one of the few parts of grading you can measure yourself. For a PSA 10, PSA’s standards say the image should be centred within approximately 55/45 to 60/40 on the front and 75/25 on the reverse.

PSA also explains that a 5% leeway is given to the front centring minimums for cards grading PSA 7 or better. Their example: a card measuring 60/40 on the front automatically meets the PSA 9 front centring standard, while a 65/35 card may be deemed to meet it if the card’s eye appeal is good. Note the word “may”. Even the measurable parts of grading leave room for judgement.

Cards that fall outside the tolerances can either receive a lower numerical grade that reflects their centring, or be given the “OC” (off-centre) qualifier, according to PSA’s standards.

Why the grader has the final say

PSA is open about the fact that grading is not purely mechanical. Its standards state that graders reserve the right to make a judgement call on a particular card based on the strength or weakness of its eye appeal, and that the final grade is based on experience, eye appeal and market acceptability. On centring specifically, PSA notes that a small variance may be permitted at the grader’s sole discretion.

In practice this means two experienced collectors can look at the same card and reach different conclusions, and neither of them is the grader. Your assessment, ours and any online “pre-grade” estimate are opinions. PSA’s grade is the only one that ends up on the label.

When a card won’t get a number at all

Not every submission comes back with a grade. PSA states it will not grade cards that show evidence of trimming, re-colouring, restoration or other tampering, or that are of questionable authenticity. These cards receive a “No Grade” code (for example, N1 is evidence of trimming). In some cases a card can be encapsulated as “Authentic” or “Authentic Altered” at the grader’s discretion. If you are buying raw vintage cards to submit, it pays to inspect edges and surfaces carefully for signs of alteration.

How to assess a card critically before you submit

  • Use good light and magnification. Tilt the card under a single light source to catch surface scratches, dents and print lines.
  • Check all four corners and edges on both sides. Whitening on the back is easy to miss and graders will see it.
  • Measure centring on the front and back rather than eyeballing it, and compare against PSA’s tolerances above.
  • Grade down, not up. If you are torn between two grades, assume the lower one when deciding whether submitting makes sense.
  • Protect it properly. A card can pick up damage between pack and grader. A penny sleeve and a semi-rigid card holder are the usual way to send cards in.

For a plain-English rundown of raw card conditions (NM, EXC, LP and so on), see our card condition guide. If you are weighing up the difference between the top two grades, our PSA 9 vs PSA 10 guide covers that in more detail.

Buying already graded, or raw

If you would rather skip the uncertainty, buying a card that has already been graded means the condition question has been settled by PSA. You can browse our PSA graded Pokémon cards, which range from modern full arts to WOTC-era Base Set and Fossil slabs. Prefer to assess cards yourself? Our ungraded singles are listed with our own condition notes and photos, and slab owners may find our accessories, including PSA-fit slab sleeves and storage cases, useful.

Important: a note on grades and expectations

This article is a general guide only and is based on PSA’s publicly available grading standards at the time of writing. PSA may update its standards at any time, so always check the official PSA grading standards before submitting. Grading is carried out solely by PSA’s graders, who apply their own professional judgement, including eye appeal. Nothing in this article, and no condition description in any of our listings, is a prediction or guarantee of the grade a card will receive. A card that appears to meet every PSA 10 criterion to you or to us may still be assessed differently by PSA. Trader’s Cache is not affiliated with PSA. Please assess cards critically and make submission or buying decisions on that basis.